Skip to content

Cookies and Milk Milkshake (w/ Mickey Cookie Garnish)

Posted in disney, Parties and Entertaining, Recipes, and Summer

Miss Jones Baking Co sent me a free package of their Organic Sugar Cookie Mix and Confetti Pop Frosting to review. I’m so excited to share the recipe for the Cookies and Milk Milkshake I made using the products they sent.

Miss Jones Baking Co Sugar Cookie Mix for my Milk and Cookies Milkshake

Being both a baker and a blogger, it’s rare that I make anything from a packaged mix. So while I was grateful for the package, I was skeptical. I’ve had issues before getting packaged sugar cookie mixes to be the proper consistency for a rolled-out dough. But to my surprise, following the exact instructions on the Miss Jones Sugar Cookie package made them the perfect consistency. When it came time to frost the cookies I was equally impressed with the frosting. I stopped buying packaged cake frosting years ago because so many of them are made with hydrogenated oils containing trans fat. So I usually just make my own buttercream from scratch. The Miss Jones Confetti Pop Frosting is 90% organic and made with coconut oil and no hydrogenated oils. It also happens to be gluten free, vegan, and straight up delicious. So now that I’m done gushing over my new favorite at-home baking brand, I’ll tell you what I made and what this blog post is actually meant to be about.

It’s summer time, and that seemed like a good excuse to make a milkshake (as if I needed an excuse). Inspired by my gifts from Miss Jones Baking Co., I decided to create a milkshake centered around one of my favorite treats—cookies and milk. I baked the cookies, crumbled them into a deliciously creamy shake,  and saved a few to garnish the glass. It’s one of those recipes that looks really fancy but is actually super easy so it’s great for company and your family will marvel at your master chef skills with no clue that you used a store-bought cookie mix. (I won’t tell if you don’t). Recipe below!


  • Miss Jones Organic Sugar Cookie Mix
  • Miss Jones Confetti Pop Frosting
  • 1/4 cup flour
  • 6 tbsp butter
  • 1 egg
  • 3 cups vanilla ice cream
  • 1 1/2 cup milk


  1. Using the cookie mix, flour, butter, and egg, follow the instructions on the package of mix for rolled cookie dough.
  2. Roll out your dough and use a cookie cutter of your choice (I chose Mickey Mouse of course), cut out just a few cookies (1 for every milkshake you intend to make, not to exceed 6 because you’ll need more cookies later to flavor the milkshake).

    Using a butter knife, make a 1/3″ slit in to the bottom of each cookie. Place on a lightly greased or non-stick cookie sheet, bake according to the package instructions, then finish baking the rest of the cookies once those are done and let cool. (Note: The next batch can just be round mounds because they will be crumbled into the milkshake later).
    When the cookies have cooled completely, set the Mickey shaped cookies aside.

  3. Place the ice cream and milk into a large blender and then crumble in round cookies. Use as many or as few of the cookies as you’d like—I recommend about 2/3 of the leftover cookies. Too little and you don’t get enough cookie flavor, too much and the milkshake is a bit too thick.
  4. Use the frosting to frost the Mickey shaped cookies. Add sprinkles, then place a cookie on the side of the glass of each milkshake and garnish the top of the cookies and milk milkshake with a sprinkling of leftover cookie crumbs. 🙂